International Center for Ethics in the Sciences and Humanities (IZEW)

Research group: Co-laborative research and innovation

How can ethics be incorporated into the sciences and humanities and other application contexts? This long-debated question always requires new contextualization and updating. On the one hand, ethics in the sciences and humanities needs concepts that are methodologically sound and practical. On the other hand, the inclusion of ethics is a situational, epistemic and social practise that needs to be understood and shaped.

In addition to the analysis and testing of co-laborative research and innovation, the research group aims at the professionalization and empowerment of researchers who implement the inclusion of ethics and at the involvement in science and innovation policy debates. One focus is on the integration of ethical and societal aspects in technological development projects.

Lead

Team

Dr. Mone Spindler

Co-laborative research, “Embedded Ethics”, STS, critical gerontology

Andreas Baur

Infrastructures × Politics, privacy and data protection, AI, (cyber-) security, technology ethics

Jacqueline Bellon

Philosophy of technology, philosophy of culture and science, epistemology, AI philosophy

Aline Franzke

Dialogical ethics guidelines, data ethics & governance, ethics of robotics, embedded ethics

Lisa Koeritz

Data science, applied ethics, operationalization

Sebastian Gießler

Ethics & epistemology of science, science and technology studies, normative philosophy of computing

Céline Gressel

Integrated research, qualitative social research, STS, VR and eye tracking

Theresa Krampe

Game studies, digital culture, media theory and media analysis

Current projects

ANKERDigital opening and development of AI ethics tools to understand and implement the effective anchoring of ethical implications in AI development. A project in the BMFTR Cluster Integrated Research (Cluster Integrierte Forschung).Lisa Koeritz, Andreas Baur

2023–2026 

BMFTR Grant no. 16SV9223

EGAREGAR is an ELSA accompanying project in the Baden-Württemberg Foundation's Autonomous Robotics research program and works together with seven technology development projects in which different robotics technologies are being developed. EGAR examines the concrete ethical and social implications of autonomous robotics using the example of specific development projects.Aline Franzke, Sebastian Gießler, Jacqueline Bellon

2023–2026

Baden-Württemberg Stiftung

PRETINADesigning the use of eye tracking technologies in gaming in a privacy-friendly, legally compliant and comprehensible manner. Researching eye-tracking-specific aspects of privacy and practical implementation of the implications derived from this. PRETINA is part of the Plattform Privatheit.Céline Gressel, Theresa Krampe

2024–2027

BMFTR Grant no. 16KIS2120
 

IZEW Ethics Tools LabAs part of the project ANKER, we are collecting ethics tools that have been (co-)developed by IZEW employees and are looking for ways to make them available to the public digitally, initially on the IZEW website.Lisa Koeritz, Mone Spindler 

Publications

  • Becker, A.; Bellon, J.; Berger, A.; Djeffal, C.; Gressel, C.; Haupt, B.; Müller, V.; Pentzold, C.; Spindler, M.:(2025): Bitte intervenieren Sie! Kollaborative Interventionen zur Stärkung des Einbezugs ethischer, rechtlicher und sozialer Aspekte in Technikentwicklungsprojekte : Ein Impulspapier aus dem Cluster Integrierte Forschung. Materialien zur Ethik in den Wissenschaften. https://publikationen.uni-tuebingen.de/xmlui/handle/10900/172056
  • Ammicht Quinn, R.; Beimborn, M.; Kadi, Selma; Köberer, N.; Mühleck, M.; Spindler, M.; Tulatz, K. (2015): Alter, Technik, Ethik. Ein Fragen- und Kriterienkatalog. Tübingen.
  • Baur, A. (2024): European Dreams of the Cloud: Imagining Innovation and Political Control. Geopolitics 29 (3), 796–820. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650045.2022.2151902
  • Baur, A. (2022): Grenzenlosigkeit in Grenzen. Zur Politik globaler Cloudinfrastrukturen. Politikum 8 (2), 44–49. https://doi.org/10.46499/2032.2377
  • Beimborn, M; Kadi, S.; Köberer, N.; Mühleck, M.; Spindler, M. (2016): Focusing on the human. Interdisciplinary reflections on ageing and technology. In: L. Nierling and E. Domínguez-Rué (eds): Ageing and Technology. Perspectives from the Social Sciences. Bielefeld: transcript. http://dx.doi.org/10.1515/9783839429570-015
  • Spindler, M.; Vondermassen, M. (2024): Ethische Aspekte der partizipativen Entwicklung von Gesundheitstechniken. In: S. Kernebeck and F. Fischer (eds): Partizipative Technikentwicklung im Sozial- und Gesundheitswesen. Interdisziplinäre Konzepte und Methoden. Bern: Hogrefe, 67–76.
  • Spindler, M. (2022): Demenz und Digitalisierung. Was aus ethischer Sicht zu beachten ist. In: Altenheim: Lösungen fürs Management 61 (12), 52–54.
  • Spindler, M. et al. (2020): How to achieve integration? Methodical concepts and methodological challenges of integrating ethical, social, legal and economic aspects into technology development. In: B. Gransche and A. Manzeschke (eds): Das geteilte Ganze. Horizonte Integrierter Forschung für künftige Mensch-Technik-Verhältnisse. Wiesbaden: Springer VS, 213–239.
  • Spindler, M. (2017): Wie sich „nicht-technische“ Aspekte vermutlich nicht in die Technikentwicklung „integrieren“ lassen. Eine Bildergeschichte. In: J. Heesen, C. Brand, B. Kröber, U. Müller and T. Potthast (eds): Ethik in den Kulturen – Kulturen in der Ethik. Eine Festschrift für Regina Ammicht Quinn. In collaboration with R. Ammicht Quinn. Tübingen: Narr Francke Attempto (Tübinger Studien zur Ethik, 8), 307–317.
  • Spindler, M.; Dietrich, J.; Ehni, H.-J. (eds) (2016): Diskurs Biogerontologie. Fachwissenschaftliche Einführung und Leitfaden für Lehrende. Wiesbaden: Springer VS. http://dx.doi.org/10.1007/978-3-658-02114-6
  • Theilen, J. T.; Baur, A.; Bieker, F.; Ammicht Quinn, R.; Hansen, M.; González Fuster, G. (2021): Feminist data protection: an introduction. In: Feminist data protection (special issue), Internet Policy Review 10 (4). https://doi.org/10.14763/2021.4.1609   

Completed projects

Kollaborative Interventionen Sub-cluster 2 of the BMBF Integrated Research Cluster2021-2024
ESTEREthical and social aspects of integrated research. A project in the BMBF Integrated Research Cluster.2021-2024
teach@tuebingen Narratives about Technology in the Global South 2021-2022
IDeAEthical and sociological aspects of mixed reality technologies for older people with visual impairment (BMBF)2018-2021
INTEGRAMHow can ethical, legal, social and economic aspects be integrated into technology development projects? (BMBF)2016-2019
MATERIAPeople in old age and technology. Ethical and social science reflections on human-technology interaction (BMBF)2016-2019
Diskurs BiogerontologieAbolishing age(ing)? Discourse project on ethical and sociological aspects of biological age(ing) research2012-2013

Co-laborative formats

AbracaData. A VR game exploring eye tracking and privacy. Gamescom, Cologne (08/2025)

DescriptionEmployeesProject

Focus: How can eye tracking be implemented in gaming? How do gamers perceive privacy, and how does the use of eye tracking in gaming affect this perception?  

 

Goals:  1.) Test the potential of eye tracking in VR gaming outside of standardized laboratory situations.

2.) Conduct an interview study on gamers' concepts of privacy and attitudes toward privacy.

3.) Initiate a mutual dialogue with gamers.

 

Participants: Visitors to the Gamescom computer games fair in Cologne and the PRETINA project team.

 

Implementation: Interested visitors to the trade fair are invited to play a VR game. In this game, they take on the role of a wizard's apprentice who must tidy up the wizard's laboratory. As the players explore the laboratory, their eye movements are measured and analyzed.

 

After the game, a qualitative guided interview takes place in which participants learn about the analysis results obtained during the game and can reflect on their attitudes toward privacy.

Céline Gressel, Theresa Krampe

 

PRETINA

"Bring mir den Hammer, Kollege Roboter!" Workshop with pupils at the TECHNOSEUM Mannheim (12/2024)

DescriptionEmployeesProject

Focus: Budding craftspeople and engineers explore together with robotics developers how robots could change their everyday working lives. 

 

Goal: Introducing vocational students to the latest robotics research and discussing ethical and social aspects of autonomous robotics.

 

Participants: Vocational students from IGMH Mannheim, researchers from FZI Informatik Karlsruhe and IZEW, employees of TECHNOSEUM Mannheim.

 

Implementation: In an ethical role play, vocational students came into direct contact with a construction site robot of the future. The robot received orders from the students and carried them out in a constructed construction site environment. The robot's functions, limitations, possibilities and also social and ethical aspects were outlined in an exploratory manner and fed back to the robot's developers. Questions were explored in dialog to what extent the interface is intuitively understandable, but also what feelings the interaction with such a machine can evoke. 

 

 

Aline Franzke

 

EGAR

Speculative toolbox for engaged methodologies. Collaborative intervention at EEAST 2024 (07/2024)

DescriptionEmployeesProject

Focus: How do researchers in the Engaged Program of Science and Technology Studies navigate their work between observation, collaboration and intervention and the associated opportunities and tensions? 

 

Goal: The intervention aimed to embark on a speculative, playful and creative joint search for new research methods. Space was created for collective self-reflection and peer support.

 

Participants: International researchers in the field of Science and Technology Studies

 

Implementation: The intervention took place as part of the annual conference of the European Association for the Study of Science and Technology (EASST) 2024 in Amsterdam. It was part of the session “Observation, collaboration, intervention. Navigating tensions and opportunities of engaged methodologies”. The intervention interrupted the academic discussion formats by offering the participants large pictures of various real tools as well as scissors, glue, pens and plasticine on a high table ensemble. Participants were invited to use the materials to create speculative tools for engaged methodologies.

 

 

Mone Spindler

 

ANKER

Traveling research boxes. Collaborative intervention on ethical aspects of project genesis (2022-2024)

DescriptionEmployeesProject

Focus: How does the project development phase affect the success of incorporating ethical, legal and social aspects into technology development projects?

 

Goal: Researching together with actors in the field and offering space for collective self-reflection and networking.

 

Participants: Researchers who want to make ethical, legal and social aspects relevant in technology development projects, project sponsors, funding bodies 

 

Implementation: Inspired by experimental design methods, a traveling research box was designed. Ten of these were sent to the participants by post and subsequently evaluated. The boxes contain deliberately analog, haptic and playful materials for researching and reflecting on key topics identified in a kick-off workshop with the participants. For example, the box contains a card game on the role of putting together the project team, which can be used to test and reflect on team constellations and the associated balancing processes.

 

Further information: Überblick über die in den Forschungsboxen enthaltenen Materialien

Céline Gressel,

Jacqueline Bellon

 

ESTER

Pick Your Scientist! Citizens and ELSA researchers in dialog at the TECHNOSEUM Mannheim (03/2023)

DescriptionEmployeesProject

Focus: What ethical, legal and social aspects can be recognized in technical artefacts?

 

Goal: Involve citizens in the discussion on ethical, legal and social aspects of new technologies and integrated research

 

Participants: Citizens and researchers who want to make ethical, legal and social aspects relevant in technology development projects.

 

Implementation: As part of the 3rd Integrated Research Conference at the TECHNOSEUM Mannheim, citizens were invited to choose a researcher to take part in the conference under the motto “Pick your scientist!”. Together, the resulting tandems were able to view the TECHNOSEUM's exhibition on the history of technology and discuss their respective perspectives on the ethical, legal and social aspects of new technology and integrated technology development in a deliberately informal and non-structured one-to-one discussion. 

 

Further information: https://integrierte-forschung.net/rueckblick-fachkonferenz-digitalisierte-lebenswelten-und-integrative-technikentwicklung/ 

Jacqueline Bellon

Céline Gressel

 

ESTER

Write a letter to your funder. Fictitious correspondence between researchers and funders (03/2023)

DescriptionEmployeesProject

Focus: How do researchers experience the influence of research funding concepts and formats on the success of integrated research? What questions and wishes do funding bodies have for researchers?

 

Goal: The aim of the intervention was to bring researchers and funding bodies/project sponsors who want to implement integrated research into a fictitious dialog about structural opportunities and difficulties. The researchers' relationship of dependency was to be undermined for a moment by creative means. 

 

Participants: Researchers from the field of integrated research and employees of project sponsors

 

Implementation: The “Write a letter to your funder” intervention took place as part of the Integrated Research 2023 symposium. The participants were invited to write a letter to their funder/project sponsor. For this purpose, they were provided with a letterhead with prepared fields in which the sender and recipient could be entered. The deliberately open subject line “What I would like to tell you” encouraged them to write their own concerns. This resulted in 18 letters containing opinions, experience reports and constructive criticism. These were made available to employees of project sponsors to read, who in turn were able to write responses to the researchers.

Céline Gressel, Mone SpindlerESTER

Integrated research 2024: Observations from the future (03/2024)

DescriptionEmployeesProject

Focus: How could and how should integrated research be organized in the future?

 

Goal: At the end of the first two sub-clusters of the Integrated Research Cluster, instead of making recommendations to funding bodies and researchers, we speculatively imagined integrated research into the future in order to create a playful momentum for change through co-laborative, fictional future design.

 

Participants: Staff of the Integrated Research Cluster and researchers from the field of integrated research

 

Implementation: A speculative intervention on the future of integrated research was carried out at the 4th Symposium on Integrated Research “Mensch-Technik-Verhältnisse transdisziplinär reflektieren und gestalten”. For this purpose, fictitious observations from the future that were as concrete as possible were formulated, presented, discussed and expanded upon, outlining what integrated research could or should look like in 2040. 

 

Further information: The “observations from the future” can be downloaded here as a PDF.

Mone SpindlerESTER