Aktuell
25.11.2026
Institutskolloquium IfP (25.11.2026) – Sword of Justice, Shield or Rubber Stamp? Constitutional Courts and Social and Labour Policies in the Long-Run
Emmanuele Pavolini (University of Milan)
Wednesday, November 25, 2026, 16:00 (c.t.)
Room 124, Institut für Politikwissenschaft, or online via Zoom
About the lecture:
Welfare state research has largely ignored national constitutional courts, although they can annul, and even rewrite, social and labour legislation. Do such courts act as a sword of justice that extends entitlements, a shield that protects existing rights, or a rubber stamp that ratifies political choices? We argue that this requires separating the direction of reform (expansion versus retrenchment) from the distribution of protection across groups. Using an original dataset of all rulings of the Italian Constitutional Court (1956–2025), we show that social welfare and health legislation is more likely than other legislation to be declared unconstitutional and rewritten, while labour and education legislation is not. Ideological heterogeneity within the Court reduces rewriting but not striking down, and older laws are more exposed. An analysis of 575 pension rulings shows that the Court levelled up a fragmented, category-based system in the 1970s and 1980s, upheld the post-1992 retrenchment reforms, and has since policed the proportionality of austerity under growing fiscal constraints. The Court has been a sword of justice against the dualisation of rights but closer to a rubber stamp on the direction of reform: it matters more for who gets what than for whether the welfare state grows or shrinks.
Emmanuele Pavolini is Full Professor of Economic Sociology at the University of Milan. He has focused his research interests in two fields: studies on welfare systems in comparative perspective, with particular attention to the social protection systems of Southern Europe and social inequalities in access to welfare services; the analysis of the labor market and the mechanisms of economic development.
Until 2024 he was co-director of the Journal of European Social Policy and expert for the European Commission on welfare issues within the European Social Policy Network (ESPN). He was until 2025 co-chair of Espanet Italia (European Social Policy Network – Italy) and was a member of the Board of Espanet Europe. Since 2020 he has also been Affiliated Professor at the Sant'Anna School of Advanced Studies, and since 2025 to the Dondena Center of Bocconi University.
The lecture will be held in English
Institutskolloquium IfP
Wednesday, November 25, 2026, 16:00 c.t.
Room 124, Institute of Political Science (IfP) or Online via Zoom: zoom.us/j/93089750663
Meeting ID: 930 8975 0663 Passcode: 142311
IfP address:
Melanchthonstr. 36 / 72074 Tübingen