Uni-Tübingen

Why is animal testing important in science?

Animal testing is conducted in both basic and applied research. In some cases, to ensure human safety, it is required by law. Basic research forms the foundation of medical and applied research. It investigates fundamental mechanisms within an organism in order to understand them and to develop new approaches to treatment. In this context, researchers often rely on animal testing. Some processes in the human or animal body can be studied in isolation. However, only in a living animal can the specific interactions between individual organs, cells, and cellular components be studied. Comparative studies across different animal species often lead to new insights. Applied research raises new questions, which in turn feed back into basic research. In other words: basic research and applied research are mutually dependent and lead to advances in clinical medicine, environmental protection, and in animal welfare.

There are numerous examples showing that results from animal experiments conducted carefully and responsibly benefit medical progress and, consequently, human beings. Here is an overview of important medical advances made possible by animal research:

2020s
mRNA vaccines against COVID-19: Rapid approval thanks to decades of preclinical work in animal models; Initial gene therapies for blood disorders
2010s
Ebola vaccine; Gene therapy for hereditary blindness
2000s
Deep brain stimulation for Parkinson's disease; Vaccinations against avian flu and cervical cancer
1990s
Meningitis vaccination; Analysis of genetic predispositions and environmental factors in the development of breast cancer; New diagnostic and therapeutic methods in the treatment of breast and prostate cancer
1980s
Organ transplants; Treatment of childhood leukemia; Breaking up kidney stones with ultrasound; Diagnosis and treatment of Lyme disease
1970s
Measles vaccination; Laser therapy for retinal detachment; First antiviral drugs
1960s
Rubella vaccination; Heart bypass surgery; Discovery of drugs to treat high blood pressure
1950s
Oral polio vaccine; Development of the first cancer chemotherapies; First cochlear implant
1940s
Treatment of leprosy
1930s
Modern anesthetics; Tetanus vaccination; Discovery of the Rhesus factor system in the blood
1920s
Discovery of insulin-mediated blood sugar regulation (initial experiments on dogs)
1900s
Blood transfusions
1900
Treatment of vitamin deficiency diseases such as rickets; Initial attempts at transplantation

The importance of animal testing for medical progress is shown by the Nobel Prizes awarded in the category Physiology or Medicine. Since 1900, the Nobel Prize in Physiology or Medicine has been awarded around 70 times to researchers who have made groundbreaking discoveries, not least through animal testing. Examples range from the discoveries of insulin and penicillin to today’s AIDS treatments and insights into the functioning of the immune system and the brain.

Thanks to animal testing, antibiotics, vaccines against diseases such as polio, and insulin for people with diabetes have been developed. Today, approximately 80 percent of children with leukemia can be cured. The treatments for this disease were developed through animal testing. Enormous progress has also been made, and continues to be made, in the treatment of cardiovascular diseases, various forms of cancer, and AIDS, as well as in surgery, based on animal research. 

Neurobiological animal experiments have made a significant contribution to improving the diagnosis and treatment of psychiatric and neurological disorders. For example, they have greatly expanded our understanding of childhood vision disorders such as strabismus and the development of myopia. The development of neuroprostheses for rehabilitation following spinal cord injuries or strokes is based on findings from experiments with rhesus monkeys. In addition, the transmission mechanisms of prion diseases such as kuru, scrapie, and Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease have been studied, which was crucial for understanding bovine spongiform encephalopathy (BSE), a disease transmissible to humans.

Are the results of animal experiments applicable to humans?

The components of human cells and the biochemical mechanisms underlying biological processes show great similarities across different animal species. Nevertheless, animal models, like cell culture models or research on organoids, are always merely models that do not fully replicate humans. Rather, models serve to make predictions. The more complex and accurate a model is in representing humans, the better its predictive power. Because of the similarities in cell and organ functions among mammals, the premise holds that results obtained in animal experiments are usually transferable to the human organism. This assumption applies to both the desired and the harmful and toxic effects of a substance.

Does the scientific community agree on the necessity of animal testing?

Science thrives on critical discourse, which also means embracing diverse perspectives. Even when it comes to the use of laboratory animals, scientists do not always agree. According to most scientists in basic biomedical research, animal experiments do provide meaningful information.

These researchers also recognize that not every result from animal experiments can be directly applied to humans. The validity of an animal experiment, like that of any other scientific experiment, is always limited and must be supplemented and scrutinized through studies using other approaches. Animal experiments therefore currently remain an essential component of science.


News and research

Latest news, scientific findings, and events related to research involving animals.